Criteria | Exemplary Exceeds Expectations |
Advanced Meets Expectations |
Intermediate Needs Improvement |
Novice Inadequate |
Total Points |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Approach to Patient Care | Approach to patient care is organized, logical, patient-centered, and cost effective, with 0 errors. 10 points |
Approach to patient care is organized, logical, patient-centered, and cost effective, with 1–3 minor errors or 1 major error. 7 points |
Approach to patient care is organized, logical, patient-centered, and cost effective, with 4–6 minor errors or 2 major errors. 5 points |
Approach to patient care is organized, logical, patient-centered, and cost effective, with 6+ minor errors or 2+ major errors. 3 points |
10 |
Differential Diagnoses (Including Problems) | All required differential diagnoses and problems are included (including worst case) and fully supported by findings. Rationale for all differential diagnoses provided. 20 points |
Most required differential diagnoses and/or problems are included (including worst case); one is not supported by findings. Rationale for most differential diagnoses provided. 18 points |
Some required differential diagnoses or problems are included (not including worst case); two are not fully supported by findings. Rationale for some differential diagnoses provided. 14 points |
Few required differential diagnoses or problems are included; more than two are not fully supported by findings. Rationale provided for few differential diagnoses. 9 points |
20 |
Case Specific questions and Rationale | Logical and systematic organization of data. Rationale provided for all answers and decisions made regarding patient care. Rationale is based on current evidence, with 0 errors. Correct terminology, spelling, and grammar. 20 points |
Logical and systematic organization of data. Rationale provided for most answers and decisions made regarding patient care. Rationale is based on current evidence, with 1–3 minor errors or 1 major error. Terminology, spelling or grammar errors (1–3). 15 points |
Minor errors in organization of data. Rationale provided for some answers and decisions made regarding patient care. Rationale is based on current evidence, with 4–6 minor errors or 2 major errors. Terminology, spelling, or grammar errors (4–6). 11 points |
Disorganized flow of data. Rationale provided for few answers and decisions made regarding patient care. Rationale is based on current evidence, with 6+ minor errors or 2+ major errors. Terminology, spelling, or grammar errors (>6). 6 points |
20 |
Plan | Comprehensive plan includes all components with no errors:
50 points |
Plan missing 1 of the identified components or plan is based on current evidence, with 1–3 minor errors or 1 major error.:
40 points |
Plan missing 2 of the identified components or plan is based on current evidence, with 4–6 minor errors or 2 major errors.:
30 points |
Plan missing >3 of the identified components and/or has safety Concerns or is based on current evidence, with 6+ minor errors or 2+ major errors.:
20 points |
50 |
Total Points | 100 |